How to feel like you're on the same team again


From: Jonathan Van Viegen

Back in my home office, Panama City

Dear Friend,

If you want a relationship that feels safe, connected, and full of mutual support, you can’t run it like a transaction.

 

Too many couples fall into the trap of scorekeeping. That’s tracking who did what, whose needs got met, whose didn’t. It’s a scarcity mindset that says:

 

“If you get yours, I won’t get mine.”

 

That mindset kills connection.

 

The antidote? Sameness.

 

Sameness is when you and your partner feel like you’re on the same team, sharing values, plans, and priorities.

 

It’s the Chinese takeout you guys like to order on Friday night while you watch your fav Netflix show together because you both love it. And because it’s a tradition that means a lot to you.

 

Being on the same page is more than appreciating what you do together. It’s knowing why you do it.

 

As an example, I want to introduce you to Terry Real - couples therapist, NYT bestselling author, and husband of 40 years:

As a colleague, I respect Terry. A lot.

 

I’m also not surprised in the least that he’s been married for 40 years. And let me tell you that it wasn’t by luck that he's been married that long.

 

It’s the effort he and his wife put into their marriage.

 

Terry posted this photo on Instagram a couple weeks back and I knew within 2 seconds what keeps him and his wife together for over 4 decades.

 

Sameness.

 

Funny thing about sameness, you see it in the couples that have it. Don’t believe me?

 

Check out the shoes these two are wearing 👇

This was an Australian/American couple we ran into on our trip to Canada this summer.

 

Wanna guess how long they were married?

 

37 years.

 

Couples that look, act, dress, and talk in the same way have figured out that our similarities are what hold us together.

 

That's because you see one another inside your relationship as one unit.

 

And so, because sameness is strong, you don’t let each other “fall out of the boat.”

 

You step in to provide support and help your partner get back to safety.

 

Whether it’s doing the dishes when they’re overloaded or initiating physical intimacy when you know it’ll help them feel loved.


Why Sameness Beats Scorekeeping

When couples focus on their differences, connection decays. It usually starts with less physical affection, then disagreements about parenting or money, then emotional distance.

 

That’s why I don’t like traditional couples therapy. It often only has you dissecting resentments.

 

You get stuck talking about what you don’t want. It’s like telling an Uber driver every place you don’t want to go. You’ll never get to your destination that way.

 

You need to strengthen the “what we want” muscle:

  • What do I want in this relationship?

  • What do you want?

  • How do we win together?

Now, you may be asking the question…

What if They Won’t Tell Me What They Want?

You can't drag someone to the table. But you can change how you invite them.

Many partners shut down because they don’t believe working on the relationship will succeed. Or they fear any feedback you give them will feel like an attack on who they are.

 

Here’s the shift you can make:

  • Remind them you’re not there to get them in trouble.

  • Make it clear you’re not keeping score.

  • Reassure them your feedback is about behavior (what they said or did), not their identity.

One great way to approach them is to introduce “and/both” thinking:

 

You can focus on your business and our marriage. I can focus on my goals and our relationship.

 

This language moves you from win/lose to win/win.

 

And if they still stay silent…

 

Silence is often not about the surface anger. It’s about fear, shame, or feeling “in trouble.”

 

Instead of pushing them for answers or to engage with you, try:

 

“If you felt safe talking to me about what’s going on, how would you know? What could I do to help you feel that way?”

 

This invites them to imagine a better outcome and lowers their defenses.

The Bottom Line

Stop trying to “win” against your partner. Start looking for sameness. Operate from abundance, not scarcity. Speak the language of we, not me versus you.

 

When you both commit to showing up better today than yesterday, and to holding each other’s well-being ahead of your own, everything changes.

In solutions and strength,

Jonathan

aka "Mr. Chosen & Cherished"


The Most Valuable Relationship Advice On The Internet!

Join thousands of couples getting the best relationship wisdom every Monday.

No spam. Just honest, useful insights.


WANT TO SHARE THIS LETTER?

social-icon
social-icon
social-icon
social-icon
social-icon

SHARE

social-icon
social-icon
social-icon
social-icon
social-icon

Jonathan Van Viegen is a couples therapist and relationship coach with over 10 years of experience helping couples rebuild trust, improve communication, and strengthen connection. Known for his direct, no-nonsense style, he’s a trusted voice on relationships and a frequent guest on podcasts and media.