A $63 Mistake That Revealed a Bigger Truth


From: Jonathan Van Viegen

My dining room table, Panama City

Dear Friend,

Welcome to the first edition of what will be a weekly newsletter from yours truly. Watch for it every Monday morning in your inbox - I’ll be sharing stories, tips, advice, and deep dives on everything relationships, with the same hard-hitting, honest, and real-world-tested perspective you’ve come to expect from me.

 

So, without further adieu, let’s dive in with this week’s story:

 

Last week, Meredith (my wife) didn’t want to tell me she got a parking ticket in Hollywood Hills - $63 just to get a better pic of the Hollywood sign. 
 

Instead of facing her fear of disappointing me, she decided to “deal with it” her own way.


And by deal with it, I mean... she paid it quietly and didn’t say a word.

 

I can only wonder — in shame — what I must’ve done in the past that made her so afraid of letting me down.

 

Now, to be fair to me, she’s also terrified of disappointing her dad.


There’s some family-of-origin stuff there that shows up fast for her when pressure hits.


So when something goes wrong, it’s like that scared little 8-year-old takes the wheel.

 

And I get it.

 

Because we don’t fight about truths in relationships.


We fight about stories.


About what something means.

 

To her: “I’m a disappointment.”
To me: “How did you not see the sign?”

 

Same moment. Different movie.

 

And both stories end the same way: There’s something wrong with her. That she’s flawed. Broken. Not enough.

 

But that’s a lie.

 

We’re not talking about who she is.


We’re talking about a moment. A $63 mistake.


And in a healthy relationship, people get to screw up without that becoming the whole damn narrative.

 

Which brings me to today’s relationship reset:


A deceptively simple exercise that works so well, it should come with a warning label:

 

⚠️ CAUTION: This might actually work.

 

I call it: “The Rewrite”

 

And its job is meant to change how you see your partner. And how they see you.
 

Here's how it works.

 

Step 1: Call out the old story. Finish this sentence, with brutal honestly: “The story I’ve been telling myself about us is…”

 

Examples:

  • “I can’t be honest with you because you’ll just get mad.”

  • “There’s no desire left here.”

  • “We’re too far gone to reconnect.”

Step 2: Spot the lie. Ask yourself: “What part of this story have I written to protect myself from pain?”

 

What belief did you invent to avoid vulnerability?

 

Yes, I’m sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but even in the most lopsided relationships, we each write parts of the story.

 

Because if you convince yourself you play no part in it, you never have to risk hoping again.


You never have to forgive. You just get to feel right.

 

But here’s the thing: If your story makes them 100% to blame, they won’t feel safe enough to even try.
 

Step 3: Rewrite the story. This is where you shift from fear to possibility. From resignation to curiosity. Where you give your relationship the off-ramp from pain. Answer this: “The new story I want to believe about us is…”

 

Examples:

  • “This unhappy dynamic feels sticky - but there’s a chance for change.”

  • “There’s more than pain here — there's also love. And we want to feel it again.”

  • “We’re not broken. We’re rebuilding.”

 

Step 4: Say it out loud. Ask this like you mean it: “What’s one thing we can each do this week to show our love in action?”

 

And come up with something tangible that each of you can do to show the other person you're still in it.


Here’s the belief shift I want to leave you with: The most dangerous story about your relationship is that there’s nothing here but pain.


And that story takes on a life of its own when you repeat it day in, day out.

 

Neither of you can change overnight. That takes time. And gas in the tank.

 

But the story you tell yourself? That can change today. And that changes everything.


Until next time — Stay curious. Stay connected. And stay far away from the lie that nothing ever changes.

In solutions and strength,

Jonathan

aka “Mr. Chosen & Cherished”


P.S. If you liked this, you can dive deeper by watching my latest YouTube video here: How To Keep Your Marriage Heathy - Without Going To Couples Therapy

In my new YouTube channel, I’m breaking down tools like this in real time. No fluff. No filters. Just straight-up help for your marriage. Subscribe here.

P.P.S. A follower sent me something the other week that hit me hard. I want to share it with you so we can talk about it next time. This question hits deep and it’s asking: what’s the path forward when your spouse is showing commitment ambivalence? Obviously, this is a topic that needs attention. And we’re going to get into it next week.

P.P.P.S. If you’ve got a burning question about your relationship, hit reply, and share it. You’ll get a personal response from me. Just an FYI, if it’s a good question that I think others could benefit from hearing the answer, it may end up in this letter. But don’t worry, I’ll always protect your identity. We’re all in this together, so learning from what others are going through can be really helpful.

P.P.P.P.S. And when you try this week’s exercise — don’t keep your win to yourself!


Let me know how it goes. Your success stories keep me going, too.


The Most Valuable Relationship Advice On The Internet!

Join thousands of couples getting the best relationship wisdom every Monday.

No spam. Just honest, useful insights.


WANT TO SHARE THIS LETTER?

social-icon
social-icon
social-icon
social-icon
social-icon

SHARE

social-icon
social-icon
social-icon
social-icon
social-icon

Jonathan Van Viegen is a couples therapist and relationship coach with over 10 years of experience helping couples rebuild trust, improve communication, and strengthen connection. Known for his direct, no-nonsense style, he’s a trusted voice on relationships and a frequent guest on podcasts and media.